The Vanished Sister by Sherry Thomas



It’s been three years since Charlotte Holmes struck a decisive blow against Moriarty's operations in Britain, three years of relative calm and benign developments. In a buoyant mood, everyone gathers at Lord Ingram's seaside cottage in North Devon for what promises to be a perfect summer holiday. Until Mrs. Watson receives an invitation from Mrs. Carstairs, her long-estranged sister, to attend a house party nearby.

Mrs. Carstairs has married spectacularly well. She is the mistress of a great manor, a doyen of all domestic arts, and still an unforgettable beauty. Now she clamors for a reconciliation with her sister. Mrs. Watson does not trust Mrs. Carstairs's motives. Yet she cannot help but feel tremors of the old admiration for this once-beloved sister.

Then Mrs. Carstairs disappears without a trace. The next day a woman is discovered floating on the waves, her build and coloring matching those of Mrs. Carstairs. But her husband insists that the corpse fished out of the Bristol Channel cannot be his wife. So where is the real Mrs. Carstairs? Would she have purposely dragged Mrs. Watson into a murder investigation? Or was it Sherlock Holmes's involvement that she needed from the very beginning? 



This is the ninth book in the Lady Sherlock series, and it still feels relatable to readers. While the series typically makes Charlotte the main protagonist, this one makes Mrs. Watson the primary character. It is still a story of sisterhood, but it shows a different side: the side of estrangement. I found myself feeling extremely close to Mrs. Watson to the point that I could begin to predict how she would react to each situation.

However, I will say that I found the mystery a little less engaging. The bond of sisterhood begins to fade, and instead a different bond begins to take precedence. To this reader, it caused a distraction from the mystery and its mechanics. I wanted to focus on different characters and their states of mind versus why the situation occurred.  This doesn’t take too much away from the novel if someone is a newbie to the series (please don’t be. Read from the beginning.) But for someone who followed from the beginning, it is easy to see the distance between the feelings and the mechanics.   

Overall, I rate this novel 4.5 out of 5 stars. 

Comments